Anas Al-Sharif en Hossam Shabat

Research methodology and accountability

We want to be transparent about how this investigation was executed. On this page, we explain the investigation design, the sources used and the analytical methods. We also describe how we sought responses from the parties involved and publish the full responses we received in connection with the research.

Investigation design

This investigation consists of two interconnected parts. First, we reconstructed how the delegitimisation campaigns against Palestinian journalists Anas Al-Sharif and Hossam Shabat developed. We examined how allegations emerged online, how different actors spread and amplified them, and how they eventually appeared in international news media. Second, we analysed how international news media reported on the two journalists and how they handled the allegations against them.

By combining these two parts, we examined both how the campaigns developed and how the allegations reached a wider audience.

 

Selection of cases

For this research, we initially analysed 32 journalists whom the Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ) identified as having been killed by Israel in Gaza. Of these, 24 were found to have been directly delegitimised. In 16 of these 22 cases, the allegations came from official Israeli channels after the journalists' deaths, primarily the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) and its spokespersons.

From this group, we selected Anas Al-Sharif and Hossam Shabat for a more in-depth analysis. Both journalists were targeted by delegitimisation campaigns before and after their deaths. They had a large reach and were prominent faces of journalistic reporting from Gaza. Their work reached an international audience.

In both cases, there was also reason to examine how allegations circulating online later appeared in international news media. The extensive media coverage of their deaths provided sufficient material for this analysis.

 

Reconstructing the online campaigns

We reconstructed the development of the campaigns against Al-Sharif and Shabat chronologically. To do so, we analysed publicly available information, including:

  • Social media posts and activity.
  • Official statements.
  • Think tank publications.
  • Other publicly available documents and statements.

We examined how the allegations developed over time, which actors spread and amplified them, and when the campaigns intensified. The analysis shows how initial attacks on the journalists' credibility developed into allegations of links to terrorist organisations. We also examined how these allegations reached a wider audience through official statements and social media.

 

Analysis of international news media

In addition to the online campaigns, we examined 98 publications from 14 international news outlets in seven Western countries.

The news outlets included:

  • United Kingdom: BBC and The Sun.
  • Netherlands: NOS and De Telegraaf.
  • France: Le Figaro and Le Parisien.
  • Germany: Tagesschau and Bild.
  • United States: The New York Times and Fox News.
  • Canada: CBC News and TVA Nouvelles.
  • Australia: News.com.au and The Australian.

We analysed how these outlets reported on the allegations against Al-Sharif and Shabat. We assessed the extent to which their coverage complied with four journalistic principles from the International Federation of Journalists' (IFJ) Global Charter of Ethics for Journalists, also known as the Bordeaux Declaration.

The four principles examined were:

1. Right of reply

Were the journalists or their employers given a meaningful opportunity to respond to the allegations?

2. Independent verification

Did the news outlets independently verify the allegations, or did they repeat statements from other actors without demonstrating independent verification?

3. Context

Did the news outlets place the allegations in the wider context of attacks on Palestinian journalists and previous delegitimisation campaigns?

4. Respectful treatment of sources

Did the news outlets treat the journalists they reported on with care, and handle the information and allegations they used responsibly?

 

Right of reply

As part of this research, Free Press Unlimited gave the parties involved an opportunity to respond to the findings and the allegations addressed in the report. We contacted actors identified in our reconstruction of the campaigns, as well as the news outlets whose publications we examined. We have published a selection of the responses in full on this page. All other responses can be found in the investigation report.

Responses from actors involved

Share this page:

I want to stay up to date

I want to stay up to date!

activity_privacy_policy
I have read and approve the Free Press Unlimited Privacy Policy