FAQs

On this page, we answer frequently asked questions about the investigation report 'From Tagging to Targeting: How online delegitimisation narratives targeting Gazan journalists were constructed and reproduced through legacy media.'

About the research

Protecting and strengthening independent journalism is central to Free Press Unlimited’s mission. Independent journalism is increasingly under pressure, particularly in conflict situations. Journalists and media worldwide are increasingly targeted by delegitimisation campaigns that undermine their credibility, safety and ability to report freely.

Through this research, Free Press Unlimited aims to provide insight into how such campaigns develop, how they affect international media coverage and what challenges they pose to journalistic standards. The aim is not to condemn individual journalists or news organisations, but to contribute to a better understanding of these developments and to support strong, independent journalism.

This research analyses how delegitimisation campaigns against two Palestinian journalists, Hossam Shabat and Anas Al-Sharif, developed and spread. It also examines how allegations against them were reproduced in international media coverage and the extent to which this coverage complied with internationally recognised journalistic standards.

The research focuses on how information spreads, how serious allegations are or are not verified, and the role journalistic standards play in reporting on conflicts. These issues have serious implications for the safety of journalists worldwide.

The research combines two methods. First, we reconstructed the delegitimisation campaigns against Hossam Shabat and Anas Al-Sharif chronologically. We used a snowball sampling method to analyse social media, official statements, think tank publications and other publicly available sources.

Second, we examined 98 publications from 14 leading news outlets in seven Western countries. We analysed how allegations against both journalists were presented and the extent to which the coverage complied with internationally recognised journalistic standards.

For this analysis, we used a coding framework based on the Bordeaux Declaration. It focuses on four core principles: independent verification, the right of reply, sufficient context and respectful treatment of sources.

The full research report contains a detailed description of the methodology.

The research is based on publicly available sources. These include official statements, social media, think tank publications, international media coverage and other publicly accessible documentation.

For the media analysis, the researchers examined 98 publications from 14 international news organisations in seven Western countries.

The full report includes all sources used, the selection criteria and the research methodology, allowing readers to assess how the research was conducted and how its findings were reached.

Journalists are civilians in armed conflict and must be protected under international law. Attacks against them are therefore unlawful. Deliberate attacks on journalists may also constitute war crimes. Civilians only become legitimate targets for the time they directly participate in hostilities. The burden of proof lies with the party to the armed conflict, and civilians must be given the benefit of the doubt.

The report provides a detailed analysis of the information Israel used to justify the attacks on the journalists. Appendix 1 explains the legal framework under international humanitarian law.

About independence and scope

Yes. Free Press Unlimited conducted the research independently. It is based on a transparent research methodology, publicly available sources and research questions established in advance. The full methodology is included in the report.

Free Press Unlimited conducted this research as part of its mandate to protect journalists worldwide. We are concerned about the large number of Palestinian journalists in Gaza whom the Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ) has identified as having been killed by Israel because of their work. CPJ has identified at least 32 such cases. Israel delegitimised 24 of these journalists by portraying them as terrorists.

To examine this pattern and how such allegations reached a wide audience, we chose to investigate two cases in detail. These cases illustrate how delegitimisation campaigns can develop, which actors play a role and how narratives can influence international media coverage.

About journalistic standards and terminology

Journalistic standards form the basis of reliable reporting, particularly during armed conflicts, when independent verification is often difficult. We examine how internationally recognised journalistic standards were applied in coverage of serious allegations against two journalists.

To understand how the allegations against these journalists gained legitimacy and visibility, we considered it relevant to examine how international media, particularly in Western countries, reported on Israel’s allegations. This issue is relevant to other conflicts and countries too. Russia and Turkey, for example, also regularly accuse journalists of terrorism or treason in official statements.

By examining how such allegations are verified, contextualised and incorporated into news coverage, we aim to contribute to careful, transparent and reliable journalism. The aim is not to condemn individual journalists or media organisations, but to contribute to public debate on conflict reporting and to strengthen journalistic quality and press freedom. In this way, we seek to help build a resilient media environment that can serve as a defence against misinformation and disinformation.

Free Press Unlimited uses the term 'genocide' in line with findings and statements by authoritative international bodies and human rights organisations. These bodies have established that there are sufficient factual grounds to use the term in relation to the situation in Gaza. As experts in international law have also stated, a court ruling is not always required before the term 'genocide' can be used, provided there is a sufficient factual basis.

In September 2025, the United Nations Independent International Commission of Inquiry on the Occupied Palestinian Territory, including East Jerusalem, and Israel concluded that Israel had committed genocide against Palestinians in Gaza. The International Court of Justice (ICJ) has issued binding provisional measures in the genocide case against Israel to prevent acts covered by the Genocide Convention. In May 2024, it ordered Israel to halt its military offensive in Rafah insofar as it could create conditions of life that might bring about the physical destruction of the Palestinian population in Gaza.

In December 2024, Amnesty International already concluded that Israel was committing genocide in Gaza. Also, in July 2025, Israeli human rights organisations B'Tselem and Physicians for Human Rights Israel also concluded that Israel was committing genocide in Gaza.

This research focuses on the delegitimisation of Palestinian journalists by Israel and the consequences for their safety.

In its previous reporting, Free Press Unlimited has also addressed propaganda and restrictions imposed on journalists by Hamas. Various press freedom organisations and Free Press Unlimited partners have also reported on attacks against journalists and other restrictions on press freedom by Hamas. See one example.

We invited the IDF and relevant Israeli ministries to respond to the report’s findings. We received a response from the IDF. You can read it here, together with the other responses we received.

Share this page:

I want to stay up to date

I want to stay up to date!

activity_privacy_policy
I have read and approve the Free Press Unlimited Privacy Policy